Understanding SIM Types: Security Risks, Attacks, and Penetration Testing

Introduction to SIM Technology

Subscriber Identity Modules (SIMs) are crucial for mobile network authentication, enabling secure communication and subscriber identification. Over time, SIM technology has evolved from removable plastic cards to embedded solutions, improving security while also introducing new attack vectors.

This article explores the security risks of different SIM types—traditional SIM, eSIM, and iSIM—and the penetration testing techniques used to assess vulnerabilities.

Traditional SIM Cards: Security Strengths and Weaknesses

What is a SIM Card?

A traditional SIM card is a physical chip that stores:

• International Mobile Subscriber Identity (IMSI)
• Authentication Key (Ki)
• Mobile network authentication and encryption credentials
• SMS and limited application data

Security Risks of Traditional SIMs

1. SIM Cloning
   • Attackers extract the Ki and create a duplicate SIM to intercept communications.
   • Older encryption algorithms (COMP128-1) are vulnerable to cryptographic attacks.
2. SIM Swapping Attacks
   • Social engineering tricks operators into transferring a subscriber’s number to an attacker’s SIM.
   • Used for identity theft, OTP bypass, and financial fraud.
3. SS7-Based Exploits
   • Exploits vulnerabilities in SS7 signaling to track locations, intercept SMS, and redirect calls.
4. IMSI Catchers (Stingrays)
   • Fake base stations force SIMs to downgrade encryption or reveal subscriber identities.

Penetration Testing for Traditional SIMs

• Ki Extraction Tests: Assess whether cryptographic attacks can extract the authentication key.
• Over-the-Air (OTA) Testing: Check if OTA updates are secure against unauthorized modifications.
• IMSI-Catcher Simulation: Evaluate resilience to fake base stations.

eSIM (Embedded SIM): Security Advantages and Risks

What is eSIM?

An eSIM is a reprogrammable SIM embedded in a device. Unlike traditional SIMs, it does not require physical swapping, enabling remote profile management and multi-network support.

Security Advantages of eSIMs

✔ Tamper-Resistant: Harder to extract authentication data than physical SIMs.

✔ Remote Management Security: Uses secure encryption for profile downloads and network switching.

✔ Reduced SIM Swap Fraud: Eliminates physical SIM transfers, reducing attack feasibility.

Security Risks of eSIMs

1. Profile Provisioning Attacks
   • If remote SIM provisioning (RSP) is compromised, attackers can hijack eSIM profiles.
   • Poorly implemented authentication mechanisms can allow unauthorized eSIM profile installations.
2. Device Theft and SIM Hijacking
   • Stolen devices with eSIMs may be susceptible to unauthorized profile resets or transfers.
3. Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks
   • If encryption is weak during remote provisioning, attackers may intercept authentication data.

Penetration Testing for eSIMs

• Remote Profile Management Testing: Assess vulnerabilities in eSIM activation and profile switching.
• Side-Channel Analysis: Test if hardware-based attacks can extract encryption keys.
• Authentication Testing: Verify security mechanisms in profile downloads and updates.

iSIM (Integrated SIM): The Future of SIM Security?

What is iSIM?

iSIM (Integrated SIM) is a software-defined SIM embedded directly within a device’s System-on-Chip (SoC). This technology eliminates the need for a separate SIM component, integrating SIM functionality into hardware.

Security Advantages of iSIM

✔ Highest Tamper Resistance: Embedded directly into secure hardware (Trusted Execution Environment, TEE).

✔ Lower Attack Surface: No physical card or removable component means reduced risk of cloning or swapping.

✔ End-to-End Secure Provisioning: Uses hardware-based cryptographic protection for profile activation.

Security Risks of iSIM

1. Firmware Exploits
   • Vulnerabilities in the device firmware can expose iSIM data.
   • Attackers can attempt code execution on the secure enclave managing iSIM.
2. Remote Provisioning Threats
   • Similar to eSIM, insecure remote management can allow profile hijacking.
3. Hardware-Level Attacks
   • Side-channel attacks, electromagnetic analysis, and fault injections could target iSIM security modules.

Penetration Testing for iSIM

• Hardware Security Testing: Evaluate resistance to fault injection and side-channel attacks.
• Secure Enclave Testing: Assess vulnerabilities in the Trusted Execution Environment (TEE) handling iSIM operations.
• Remote Provisioning Security Audits: Identify weaknesses in over-the-air provisioning mechanisms.

Comparing Security of SIM, eSIM, and iSIM

SIM TypeSecurity StrengthsSecurity WeaknessesTraditional SIMSimple authentication, physically removableCloning, SIM swap fraud, SS7 attackseSIMRemote management security, tamper-resistantProfile hijacking, remote provisioning risksiSIMFully integrated, highly secure, no physical attack surfaceFirmware vulnerabilities, hardware-level attacks

Best Practices for Securing SIM Technology

🔒 Use Strong Authentication

• Enforce two-factor authentication (2FA) to prevent SIM-based fraud.
• Implement Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) for secure authentication.

📡 Monitor Network Activity

• Detect anomalous signaling messages that may indicate SS7 or Diameter attacks.
• Implement firewalls to block unauthorized SIM-related traffic.

🔬 Conduct Regular Penetration Testing

• Test for vulnerabilities in SIM provisioning, over-the-air updates, and network authentication.
• Simulate attacks like SIM swapping and IMSI-catcher scenarios.

📱 Secure Remote Provisioning

• Encrypt eSIM and iSIM provisioning data with strong cryptographic standards.
• Implement mutual authentication for network-device communication.

P1 Security Vulnerability Knowledge Base (VKB)

P1 Security provides a comprehensive Vulnerability Knowledge Base (VKB), which includes an extensive database of telecom security vulnerabilities. Our VKB helps telecom operators and security professionals stay ahead of emerging threats by providing up-to-date information on exploits, attack vectors, and mitigation strategies. Contact us to learn more about how P1 Security can help protect your mobile infrastructure.

💡 Need expert telecom security solutions? P1 Security specializes in penetration testing, telecom security assessments, and attack mitigation. Contact us to secure your mobile network infrastructure today!

‍